Stop Hiring the Wrong Sales Person – Part 1

Most bad sales hires start before the first interview. They start with a job description you dusted off in a hurry, posted the same day, and never matched to what the business needs.

In this episode of Sales Against the Odds, host Lee Brumbaugh kicks off a three-part series on how to stop hiring the wrong salesperson. For founders and owners who’ve watched sales hires come and go without helping the business grow, Part 1 is about setting the table: the groundwork to do before you go looking for your next seller.

Lee walks through five areas to tighten up first. Rewrite the job description around what the role has to get done. Define your ideal customer, including its industry, sales cycle and decision-makers. Decide whether you need a hunter, a farmer or a hybrid. Narrow the core responsibilities so reps don’t drift to the easiest work. Finally, define what success looks like, with a realistic compensation plan and a vision that draws in top talent.

He also explains why hiring from a competitor often lands you their B, C or even D players, and why the seller who pushes back on your OTE numbers is often the one you want.

Key takeaways:

  • Why your job description should reflect the work you need done, not the last person who held the role
  • How a clear ICP, sales cycle and set of decision-makers point you to the right type of seller
  • Why focused responsibilities and a realistic, compelling vision of success attract and keep A players

Our Recent Podcasts

Stop Hiring the Wrong Sales Person – Part 1

Hiring the wrong salesperson can cost your business more than time and money. In Part 1 of this three-part series, Lee Brumbaugh shares why successful sales hiring starts long before the interview. Learn how to define the right role, identify your ideal customer, and set clear expectations to attract salespeople who can actually drive growth.

How to Build Amazing Teams Ready to Scale with Derrick Smith

Growth doesn’t come from strategy alone. It comes from humble leaders, the right people, and grit. In this episode, Derrick Smith shares why leaders almost always wait too long to address people issues, and why feedback should be constant so problems are never a surprise.
How Consultative Selling Builds Customer Trust with Larry Freedman

How Consultative Selling Builds Customer Trust with Larry Freedman

Many salespeople build relationships but never move the needle. Larry Freedman—a sales leader with 30+ years in pharma—reveals why challenging the status quo and asking the right questions turns relationships into action and customers into advocates.

Related Articles

Share This Episode

Episode Highlights

(00:00) Introduction to the “Stop Hiring the Wrong Salesperson” series


(02:10) Rethink the job description


(04:17) Define your target customer


(06:11) Matching the sales cycle and decision-makers


(07:43) Hunter, farmer, or hybrid: defining the type of role


(08:58) Defining core responsibilities


(10:16) Defining what success looks like


(12:28) Recap: setting the table before you hire

About the Host

Lee Brumbaugh
Host of Sales Against the Odds

Grow Your Sales with Expert Insights

Looking for practical strategies to strengthen your sales organization? Each session is designed to help you address real sales challenges with proven strategies, practical takeaways, and ideas you can put into action to drive sustainable growth.